Seeds vs. Cuttings: The advantages and disadvantages of propagating through seeds and cuttings

(Sandie Clarke/Unsplash)


Plant propagation is a key to expanding crop populations and achieving desirable yields. It is a fundamental process that allows farmers to reproduce and multiply their chosen plant varieties. Two widely utilized methods are propagation from seeds and propagation from cuttings. Each method presents its own set of advantages and disadvantages, making it crucial for farmers and growers to carefully consider which approach to adopt.

Advantages of propagation from seeds

High genetic diversity. Seeds carry a unique combination of genetic material inherited from both parents, leading to greater adaptability and resilience to changing environmental conditions. This diversity can provide crops with a higher chance of survival and improved resistance to diseases, pests, and climatic variations.

Cost-effective. Seeds can be easily collected or purchased relatively cheaply, making them accessible to farmers, gardeners, and agricultural enthusiasts. Moreover, seeds can be stored for extended periods, allowing for future use, reducing the need for frequent purchases.

Disadvantages of propagation from seeds

Longer time to mature. Propagation from seeds typically requires a longer time to reach maturity compared to other methods, such as cuttings. Seeds undergo a series of developmental stages, including germination, seedling establishment, and vegetative growth, before they can produce flowers or fruits. This longer timeframe can delay the onset of desired yields and may require additional resources and patience from farmers.

Variability. Seeds possess inherent genetic variability, which can lead to diverse traits among offspring. While this diversity can be advantageous, it also introduces an element of uncertainty. The resulting plants may exhibit variations in characteristics such as growth rate, size, taste, and disease resistance. This variability can pose challenges for farmers seeking uniformity and consistency in their crops.

Vulnerable to environmental factors. Seedlings are generally more vulnerable to environmental factors compared to plants propagated through other methods. Young seedlings require careful nurturing and protection from adverse conditions such as extreme temperatures, heavy rainfall, pests, and diseases. Ensuring their survival and healthy growth demands additional attention and resources, which may increase the overall costs of seed propagation.

Advantages of propagation from cuttings

Faster reproduction. Propagation from cuttings offers faster plant reproduction than seed propagation. By taking a part of a mature plant, such as a stem or root cutting, it is possible to produce genetically identical clones. This method bypasses the time-consuming process of seed germination and seedling establishment, enabling growers to obtain mature plants more quickly and efficiently.

Uniformity. Cuttings produce genetically identical copies of the parent plant, resulting in a high degree of uniformity among offspring. This uniformity is valuable in commercial agriculture, where consistency in crop characteristics, appearance, and productivity is often essential. Additionally, uniformity facilitates the mechanization of farming practices, such as harvesting, as the plants have similar growth patterns and maturation rates.

Disadvantages of propagation from cuttings

Genetic uniformity. While genetic uniformity is advantageous in some contexts, it can also be a disadvantage. Propagating plants from cuttings results in clones that have identical genetic makeup to the parent plant. This lack of genetic diversity can make crops more susceptible to diseases, pests, and environmental changes. A single vulnerability affecting the parent plant could potentially impact the entire population of cloned plants.

High cost and more labor. Propagation from cuttings often demands more resources, both in terms of labor and materials. Preparing and maintaining suitable rooting conditions, such as appropriate humidity levels and rooting hormones, can be time-consuming and expensive. Additionally, the need for skilled labor to execute cutting techniques accurately may add to the overall cost of this propagation method.

While each method has its advantages and disadvantages, there are instances where utilizing both methods can be advantageous.  By combining the use of seeds and cuttings, farmers can harness the benefits of genetic diversity, adaptability, and uniformity. They can start by propagating plants from seeds to introduce genetic diversity and explore new varieties. This allows for the selection of desirable traits and the adaptation of crops to different environmental conditions.

Once suitable varieties have been identified, farmers can use cuttings to propagate those specific plants and ensure uniformity in offspring. This approach enables the retention of desired traits and characteristics, providing consistency in crop quality, appearance, and productivity.

For example, strawberries produce seeds that can be collected and used for propagation. The seeds can be obtained from ripe strawberries and sown in a suitable growing medium. However, the strawberries grown from seeds may not necessarily resemble the parent plant. Strawberries can also be propagated through vegetative means, specifically through cuttings. This method ensures that the new plants are genetically identical to the parent plant, preserving the desired characteristics.

The combination of seed propagation and cuttings can provide an opportunity for continuous improvement and optimization. By carefully selecting and propagating superior plants from seeds, farmers can then take cuttings from those plants to maintain and enhance their desirable traits over time.

What is your reaction?

In Love
Not Sure

You may also like

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in:CROPS